Why I worry about Dalit is because if we keep one limb weak, if they join Muslims or if we are not together and we Hindus lose to Muslims, Brahmans or Dalits are massacred at hand of Muslims, or converted en-mass by Christians, I will be one feeling the most loss.
While others bother about only how to get more govt jobs and more money, cant sacrifice it for 100 years. While Dalits were forced to make worse sacrifices for 1000 years still they remained Hindu.
Cast card is being overplayed by rich among befitting group. Inclusion of financial basis is only solution and is a challenge, because of vote bank policy.
(1) first step can be to include financial basis within quota and identify BPL families in general class, keep a common minimum financial basis in all groups. LIKE 2 lakh per family to be maximum income to avail reservation
(2)Then abolish cast and keep only financial basis.
To include financial basis, one doesn't need to put country on fire, every Hindu is our brother even if he is taking more benefits. Plz, no passions against Dalits and lower OBC brothers.
While others bother about only how to get more govt jobs and more money, cant sacrifice it for 100 years. While Dalits were forced to make worse sacrifices for 1000 years still they remained Hindu.
Cast card is being overplayed by rich among befitting group. Inclusion of financial basis is only solution and is a challenge, because of vote bank policy.
(1) first step can be to include financial basis within quota and identify BPL families in general class, keep a common minimum financial basis in all groups. LIKE 2 lakh per family to be maximum income to avail reservation
(2)Then abolish cast and keep only financial basis.
To include financial basis, one doesn't need to put country on fire, every Hindu is our brother even if he is taking more benefits. Plz, no passions against Dalits and lower OBC brothers.
A very good speech by Kanshi Ram
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-6JKjQm6wQ
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This blog is continuation to my previous blogs
http://danasurdanu.blogspot.nl/2015/05/hindu-liberalismhipocrisy-and-facade.html
http://danasurdanu.blogspot.nl/2015/06/why-media-is-anti-modi.html
Summary: I support that there should be perfect equality and no favours. Reservations were introduced because land reforms were not completely implemented. 30 % High Cast and upper OBC caste own 99% of land in India still to this day. It was sought as win win situation, because upper strata was not willing to give land (which had much more monetary value) and lower strata cant be kept under same condition as they are living in for times immemorial (after all sc/st reservation is less than their population share).
It is possible that there is no need for lands, govt jobs when we have industry based economy where most earn by working in private firms, like Europe.
In that situation may be after 50 years reservation can be annulled in say 20 years time frame. After taking into confidence each part of society. Unity is more important than few jobs. Unity will bring thousand times much more prosperity than we can ever get by having more share in jobs. USA, UK, Germany have not grown by reservation, nor by people serving in govt jobs.
A more reasonable solution is income based reservation, but we are pushing the rock for long without rock showing any signs of movement, it can injure us. Instead we can work on industrialization, investment. Uplift the poor, marginalize the rich among sc/st, remove the better off casts from OBC list, weaken the need for reservation. Make governance transparent where there is no black money and nobody can fool system, where each penny in pocket of each citizen is declared and white. I hope after such steps are implemented then you have cut the rock and made it smaller now you can remove it from the road which leads to equality.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This blog is continuation to my previous blogs
http://danasurdanu.blogspot.nl/2015/05/hindu-liberalismhipocrisy-and-facade.html
http://danasurdanu.blogspot.nl/2015/06/why-media-is-anti-modi.html
Summary: I support that there should be perfect equality and no favours. Reservations were introduced because land reforms were not completely implemented. 30 % High Cast and upper OBC caste own 99% of land in India still to this day. It was sought as win win situation, because upper strata was not willing to give land (which had much more monetary value) and lower strata cant be kept under same condition as they are living in for times immemorial (after all sc/st reservation is less than their population share).
It is possible that there is no need for lands, govt jobs when we have industry based economy where most earn by working in private firms, like Europe.
In that situation may be after 50 years reservation can be annulled in say 20 years time frame. After taking into confidence each part of society. Unity is more important than few jobs. Unity will bring thousand times much more prosperity than we can ever get by having more share in jobs. USA, UK, Germany have not grown by reservation, nor by people serving in govt jobs.
A more reasonable solution is income based reservation, but we are pushing the rock for long without rock showing any signs of movement, it can injure us. Instead we can work on industrialization, investment. Uplift the poor, marginalize the rich among sc/st, remove the better off casts from OBC list, weaken the need for reservation. Make governance transparent where there is no black money and nobody can fool system, where each penny in pocket of each citizen is declared and white. I hope after such steps are implemented then you have cut the rock and made it smaller now you can remove it from the road which leads to equality.
National Interest Should be at Heart
We
gave up quarter of country to enemies, few jobs given to and taken from own
people should not be issue.
More than that we spend on Kashmir and minority funds, minority educational institution, urdu teachers, madarsa, haj, Bangladeshi Muslim emigrants every year. Much more billions of dollars investment we loose because of anarchy, terrorism, jihad etc. Kashmir alone costs us more than two lakh crores every year. Why so much brouhaha for few jobs, did not we agree to do everything for sake of unity and put nation above self?
More than that we spend on Kashmir and minority funds, minority educational institution, urdu teachers, madarsa, haj, Bangladeshi Muslim emigrants every year. Much more billions of dollars investment we loose because of anarchy, terrorism, jihad etc. Kashmir alone costs us more than two lakh crores every year. Why so much brouhaha for few jobs, did not we agree to do everything for sake of unity and put nation above self?
I have
no problem, if my own Hindu brothers who were suppressed both by Muslims and
some Hindus, if they get few jobs from reservation. But yes seeing some rich off claiming reservation in the name of caste really hurts others who work hard to get a job.
India was under Muslim & Christian rule for 1000 years prior to 1947. Muslims destroyed each school, each university, each factory, each masons workshop. But according to liberals, it was Brahmins only who suppressed masses, according to Brahmins it is the reservation which is biggest discrimination and not the Kashmiri Pandits forced expulsion. Everyone avoids real enemy and looks for alibi.
In any case there are only 10-20 million jobs, 1-2 million jobs here and there wont change fate of country and wont employ 95% population.
Govt employees dont work, if they have to work like in private companies, they will not clamour for govt job. A govt employee officially works around 180 days only, on paper, off paper much less. Govt employees essentially loot the country and corrupt Indians want more share in loot, everyone wants it. Until they dont get job, they blackmail govt for job, vacancies must be filled, there should be more schools (not so that more poor get education) so that more people get job. When they get the position they say we are not getting such and such facility and so on, and then look for opportunity to strike, the habit of blackmailing doesn't go away.
Habit starts very early, high school guys want to pass Matriculation by cheating only, then they get certificate and want jobs by bribing, leaking paper, changing the person in exam, everything. I have studied in Govt school, college university all the way. My own experience of Matriculation (10th) and Intermediate (12th) says, 90% guys were not worthy of passing but they passed by cheating. I saw my school teachers going to help their son in cheating, they contact exam checker to get higher grade.
Most often salaries and facility in govt job is much higher than justified, in addition surplus bribe, it is for this additional loot that everyone clamours for.
Cast and employee unions are used to blackmail govt, more the numbers, higher the blackmailing power, all groups have done that, Harijan sabha, or Jat Union, or Waishya Union, or Auto-Rickshaw union, they all have same goal, work less and blackmail govt.
Indians always ask everything from Govt, but dont agree for basic things, dont fulfil basic duties, which are necessary for national interest. No reflection, because nobody even questioned it. One video of Golwalkar Guruji is a must listen.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5sR0wNfZKA
Unrealistic Expectation
A semi-literate Indian mostly thinks that Govt. has a minting machine, Govt. should create more positions, and pay them more salary, while there is no net production, that's how everyone can get employment. There is no need for peace, investment etc. No need for hard work. Politicians and news traders have fuelled this unrealistic expectation for their own sake.
Contrary to that masses have to create GDP and an efficient government will have less employees. If everyone is teacher and clerk then from where will Govt. get tax, to pay them? And where they will get that many students/offices where those staff could be utilized?
Govt is there for providing infrastructure, setting rules and regulation. But income has to come from some production, service etc.
Govt employees dont work, if they have to work like in private companies, they will not clamour for govt job. A govt employee officially works around 180 days only, on paper, off paper much less. Govt employees essentially loot the country and corrupt Indians want more share in loot, everyone wants it. Until they dont get job, they blackmail govt for job, vacancies must be filled, there should be more schools (not so that more poor get education) so that more people get job. When they get the position they say we are not getting such and such facility and so on, and then look for opportunity to strike, the habit of blackmailing doesn't go away.
Habit starts very early, high school guys want to pass Matriculation by cheating only, then they get certificate and want jobs by bribing, leaking paper, changing the person in exam, everything. I have studied in Govt school, college university all the way. My own experience of Matriculation (10th) and Intermediate (12th) says, 90% guys were not worthy of passing but they passed by cheating. I saw my school teachers going to help their son in cheating, they contact exam checker to get higher grade.
Most often salaries and facility in govt job is much higher than justified, in addition surplus bribe, it is for this additional loot that everyone clamours for.
Cast and employee unions are used to blackmail govt, more the numbers, higher the blackmailing power, all groups have done that, Harijan sabha, or Jat Union, or Waishya Union, or Auto-Rickshaw union, they all have same goal, work less and blackmail govt.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5sR0wNfZKA
Merit and Income based Reservation
People talk of merit, I don’t think much merit is required for the 95% of Govt jobs. Any educated sane person can perform work of a clerk, a peon, a second class officer is only little more demanding, not much. They dont develop rocket science at govt jobs. The reason why people want govt job is that they dont want to work and they want more black money, more loot.
Myth of some caste considering themselves meritorious is flawed. If a dalit had been treated equally they would have been equally competent. All humans groups have almost equal capacity. Anyways 99% Govt. employees have used their merit and skill to invent new ideas on how to loot the country and hide the black money.
How about no second person from a family being eligible to apply for govt job?
If you think about our body, no wise person will neglect his hand, he will love his and and it will grow strong. If it is another body then we like to enslave it, or wont care to give its nutrition food to that body. Blaming inefficiency on reservation is foolish. Court, Police, Hospitals all are inefficient in India, and despite the fact that mostly are manned and controlled by non-dalits.
Problem of high cast poor remain, but they have relatives, friends who are well off and who can guide them, in uplifting from poverty. I think all high cast well off people should not take govt jobs so that more is available for poors, like LPG subsidy. Compared to high cast poor, most of dalits have almost nobody in family who owns land, who is well educated or holds a good position in govt office, they cant get help.
The kind of talk most people do, is not factual, not worth listening, it is mostly rumour. Most of caste groups have many rumours related to their cast, leaders, politics etc, which is far away from the reality, people always lean to extreme on other side.
There is lot more on stake, let us vow to maintain peace and brotherhood at all costs, let us be ready to loose or gain few jobs or things like that, much more awaits us in future if we can do that. See how Modiji manages everything, sacrificing even his respect many times.
I support economy based reservation but I have seen many guys who are economically very strong, but on paper earn very less and fall under BPL etc. Everyone knows how easy it is to hide income and get certificate for very low income. If there is economy based reservation, many in upper middle class will get low income certificate and 25% SC/ST will get 1% and 40% lower OBC will get 10% job, rest 89% jobs will go to 30 % general category and upper OBC (like Kurmi and Yadavs). That would be unfair.
Currently 45% jobs are taken by General class who constitute only 15 % of population. This is still a good scenario and more than fair.
Progress of a nation is also determined by what portion people are really skilled, who can think and follow logic, scientific method, ability for critical thinking and overcoming self-bias. Sad to say in India only 0.5% Indians might be having such qualities, compared to china (1%), USA and western Europe (5%). Merit is required for developing cutting edge technology, but most educated Indians have no interest in that, those who have they leave to USA and other countries, rightly as staying in India is like playing flute to buffalo. Most of PhD and MSc research in India are copying, plagiarism, with no original work, people like it.
Most of Indians are frog of well, they have no idea about logic, technical advancement, efficiency. Even though India has done well in IT sector, in most other sectors we cant compete with very small countries like singapore, norway, denmark etc. Indians have no vision, but even a ricksha-wala, pan-wala think they know everything and are most smart. Wickedness cant replace hard mental work and ability to crookedness is not smartness, it is hollowness. Morality is about strength and wisdom, but for Indians it is foolishness.
Progress of a nation is also determined by what portion people are really skilled, who can think and follow logic, scientific method, ability for critical thinking and overcoming self-bias. Sad to say in India only 0.5% Indians might be having such qualities, compared to china (1%), USA and western Europe (5%). Merit is required for developing cutting edge technology, but most educated Indians have no interest in that, those who have they leave to USA and other countries, rightly as staying in India is like playing flute to buffalo. Most of PhD and MSc research in India are copying, plagiarism, with no original work, people like it.
Most of Indians are frog of well, they have no idea about logic, technical advancement, efficiency. Even though India has done well in IT sector, in most other sectors we cant compete with very small countries like singapore, norway, denmark etc. Indians have no vision, but even a ricksha-wala, pan-wala think they know everything and are most smart. Wickedness cant replace hard mental work and ability to crookedness is not smartness, it is hollowness. Morality is about strength and wisdom, but for Indians it is foolishness.
Hyporcisy
Too much bragging doesnot change reality. A Rajput neighbour of mine had Ration shop licence on the name of Dhobi (SC). Everything is drama, all castes want reservation. 90% Indians are corrupt.
The tweet above is just a false show off, braggadocio. This hypocrisy has made us slave. It transcends cast and language, but higher the cast in traditional hierarchy, more the bragging. Instead of pointing fingers to others, first people should point finger to their own relatives in villages. But they never do that. They dont feel it when ask low caste to sit in separate row in village functions, separate colonies (tola). Its royal to have 5 servants, driver etc.
Most people even in facebook age, like foolish groups like Jat group, Rajput group, Brahmin group, Srivastava group, Yadav Group, false slogans and pictures are shared. They understand nothing about human psychology, character and human capacity. Just wearing a tie or suit doesn't make you a civilized man. Almost all caste groups connect themselves to Rama, Krishna, Parshurama or some other great person. Its totally illogical. It can be possible that genes of Rama is in only 1000 people and there are 5 rapist in those 1000! It doesn't mean anything. Every one claims to be son of Ram, but nobody feels outraged when his birthplace is desecrated, nobody feels outraged when Krishnas Janmbhoomi is desecrated. Few thousand from one billion claimants of Ram's legacy would be enough. For thousand year, each Hindu family was raped, each village temple was disrespected but all our bravery and glory was gone. Each of us have paid Jajiya, but we dont even speak about it in history, instead glorify Aurangjeb in articles. Does anyone dare to speak it to a Muslim?
Do we feel outraged when Nikhil Wagle, Jakir Nayak, Owaisi, Arundhati Rai, Teesta Setalwad who continuously insult nation and society are sheltered by our own high class society? Why dont first expel them out of caste, dont marry or eat with these Shekhar Guptas, Pranay Rai, Achutanandan and all? Why do we elect goons like Anant Singh?
I have a personal experience in 2006, During my first year bachelors, I wrote a petition against Govt soft policy on terrorism after 11 July 2006 blasts in Mumbai, I intended to get at-least 100 signatures from students, some from profs and send to President of India. Barring 2-3, all my batch-mates said you are creating a communal problem, we have Muslim cooks in our mess, some said there are two Muslims in fourth year they will screw us. None of my 5-6 Jat batch-mates had courage to sign it (else they always talked about their bravery, race and unity), I forcibly took 20-30 signatures. Some guys called themselves Pahari Thakur and Rajasthani Royal Rajput, they all were pissing in their pants. There was one Sikh, he also didn't sign, but before he used to said that his ancestors were riding horse and were jamindars in Multan. To my surprise half of my friends who had RSS background they also backed out. They go sakha for yoga and time pass, to feel better.
Among language groups, one may find Bengalis, Maratha, Punjabis all have same problem. It is appalling to see how Bengalis feel proud of their culture when they have more than 50% share in mental bankruptcy, anti-national ideology; the kind of shit this fake culture produces, like Arundhati Rai, Amratya sen and Bong profs in US universities who write petitions against Modi.
Recently Nitish Kumar bragged that his father was freedom fighter. As far as I know, there were few freedom fighter those days, and this freedom fighter thing was given to everyone who had fight with his neighbour and went to jail, thieves who went jail, who didn't pay some tax and went to jail. It would be worthwhile not to get swayed and dig everything to bottom, before believing it. Even if his father had some contribution, it would still be a bad name to have fathered such a traitor for whom terrorist Ishrat Jahan is daughter, Yasin Bhatkal is son but martyrs who died at border are not worthy of respect.
Most people even in facebook age, like foolish groups like Jat group, Rajput group, Brahmin group, Srivastava group, Yadav Group, false slogans and pictures are shared. They understand nothing about human psychology, character and human capacity. Just wearing a tie or suit doesn't make you a civilized man. Almost all caste groups connect themselves to Rama, Krishna, Parshurama or some other great person. Its totally illogical. It can be possible that genes of Rama is in only 1000 people and there are 5 rapist in those 1000! It doesn't mean anything. Every one claims to be son of Ram, but nobody feels outraged when his birthplace is desecrated, nobody feels outraged when Krishnas Janmbhoomi is desecrated. Few thousand from one billion claimants of Ram's legacy would be enough. For thousand year, each Hindu family was raped, each village temple was disrespected but all our bravery and glory was gone. Each of us have paid Jajiya, but we dont even speak about it in history, instead glorify Aurangjeb in articles. Does anyone dare to speak it to a Muslim?
Do we feel outraged when Nikhil Wagle, Jakir Nayak, Owaisi, Arundhati Rai, Teesta Setalwad who continuously insult nation and society are sheltered by our own high class society? Why dont first expel them out of caste, dont marry or eat with these Shekhar Guptas, Pranay Rai, Achutanandan and all? Why do we elect goons like Anant Singh?
I have a personal experience in 2006, During my first year bachelors, I wrote a petition against Govt soft policy on terrorism after 11 July 2006 blasts in Mumbai, I intended to get at-least 100 signatures from students, some from profs and send to President of India. Barring 2-3, all my batch-mates said you are creating a communal problem, we have Muslim cooks in our mess, some said there are two Muslims in fourth year they will screw us. None of my 5-6 Jat batch-mates had courage to sign it (else they always talked about their bravery, race and unity), I forcibly took 20-30 signatures. Some guys called themselves Pahari Thakur and Rajasthani Royal Rajput, they all were pissing in their pants. There was one Sikh, he also didn't sign, but before he used to said that his ancestors were riding horse and were jamindars in Multan. To my surprise half of my friends who had RSS background they also backed out. They go sakha for yoga and time pass, to feel better.
Among language groups, one may find Bengalis, Maratha, Punjabis all have same problem. It is appalling to see how Bengalis feel proud of their culture when they have more than 50% share in mental bankruptcy, anti-national ideology; the kind of shit this fake culture produces, like Arundhati Rai, Amratya sen and Bong profs in US universities who write petitions against Modi.
Recently Nitish Kumar bragged that his father was freedom fighter. As far as I know, there were few freedom fighter those days, and this freedom fighter thing was given to everyone who had fight with his neighbour and went to jail, thieves who went jail, who didn't pay some tax and went to jail. It would be worthwhile not to get swayed and dig everything to bottom, before believing it. Even if his father had some contribution, it would still be a bad name to have fathered such a traitor for whom terrorist Ishrat Jahan is daughter, Yasin Bhatkal is son but martyrs who died at border are not worthy of respect.
SC/STs जाति व्यव्स्था के लिये बाह्मनों को दोष देते हैं
लेकिन अब ये SC/ST आपस में जाति क्यों नही मिटाते ?
अंतर्जातीय विवाह आपस में क्यों नही करते ?
क्या बाह्मण रोकने आते हैं ???
सच ये है कि ये भी आपस में उंच नीच रखते हैं ।
How about no second person from a family being eligible to apply for govt job?
Some people think, that their group of people are Ghoda,
why not they give up govt job and go to private sector? Fact is they are
used to being in power, and enjoying corruption, cant see others enjoy
it. Why a horse needs to eat share of donkeys? Everyone is horse in his house, it doesn't bring anything to donkeys.
Cast Bias is Reality
A common excuse for cast bias is reservation. Now a boy born in OBC family, he will be general for all purposes, if he doesn't make OBC certificate. Will high cast people marry him? No, his caste will be asked. High caste people marry Americans, and other white races, but not a fellow Hindu of low caste.
It is not based on some brotherhood but opportunism, most people don't know what they do. They are too arrogant, corrupt and cunning to have or listen any sane voice.
I have some experience is from my bachelors, where boys from UP hated Dr. Ambedkar and Mayawati more than any other leader. Although I have been hardcore BJP guy, but still I think Mayawati was better than Mualayam, Lalu, Sonia and Nitish and bias against Mayawati was based on cast. Dr Ambedkar was as good as Savarkar.
I have some experience is from my bachelors, where boys from UP hated Dr. Ambedkar and Mayawati more than any other leader. Although I have been hardcore BJP guy, but still I think Mayawati was better than Mualayam, Lalu, Sonia and Nitish and bias against Mayawati was based on cast. Dr Ambedkar was as good as Savarkar.
There is still very strong caste bias on ground, High cast Bhumihars, Rajput, Brahmins in bihar dont treat others as equal in villages. Practice of caste-ism is highest among most influential castes.
Jat in western UP, Punjab, Hariyana, act like goons in case of dalits and others.
Many of neo-middle class have not seen how 60% poor live in villages and slums. People are deaf and dumb, there is no TV, internet etc, half of villages in bihar have no connection to roads and they live like in islands. More than half of people are landless, skill-less since times immemorial. Babies are born in house as hospitals are far away. Mostly high caste people and upper OBC , who constitute most of affluent have made no attempts to address grievances of poor, dalits, adivasis. They don't care about it. The voice of downtrodden doesn't matter to them. They are dumb blockheads to high caste, they cant be civilized or taught, this is the same thing which fuels the fire. Dalits and low caste feel afraid and they talk silently in small groups which is not visible on the surface. This no reservation demand is one sided, only few castes have voice, other voice are suppressed. These unheard voices beneath have create tremors in the past, perfect example is Bihar where all positions were occupied by high casts in pre-mandal era and high cast Maithili Brahmins, Kayasths, Bhumihars called shots everywhere ignoring majority of masses.
It is among all castes, every caste discriminates the castes lower to it. Many know that Ranvir Sena committed many massacres of dalits in Bihar but few know it was Kurmis who burnt alive 40 dalits in Belchhi in Nalanda Bihar. But they cry when Bhumihars mistreat them. Most OBC landlords act no different from high cast land lords.
http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/india/terroristoutfits/massacres.htm
http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/india/terroristoutfits/massacres.htm
Simmering discontent among low castes in villages is very high often, which anti-nationals like Lalu, nitish, mulayams exploit. In many cases it is not the justice but greed which fuels politics. Like Yadavs in UP and Bihar, they are looting and consider loot as their birth right, even If mulayam makes Pakistan of entire UP. Same with all other castes. Every one wants to loot.
Oppression, Alibi for Hard Work
Half of OBC dont need reservation, but they exercise their numerical strength to enjoy the perks of corruption. Paswans of Bihar are as good as lower OBC but still they enjoy easy life as SCs and real SC like chamar and mushar dont get jobs, Meena of Rajsthan swallow all the jobs meant for poor STs of Jharkhand, Orrisa, and Chhatisgarh.
Reservation has become alibi for rich neo rich among SC/ST and OBC, to work less and get jobs. I have seen many OBC, SC/ST, who by no means will face any oppression, but it is these people who enjoy the reservation and Govt perks. They want this oppression concept to exist. Poor OBC and SC/ST still don't benefit. If there is any conscience, rich OBC and SC/ST should leave opportunity for poor.
In many places like in Mumbai, Delhi etc, nobody wants to know about cast, there is no difference. But many who enjoy reservation benefits they wish to keep discrimination on record so that they can keep enjoying benefits. There is a wish that if they are always labelled as low caste, they can always keep enjoying benefits.
Hijack of Cast Problem by Anti-nationalists
You can always find AAPtards, Congressis, pseudoMarxists (don't give them respect by calling Marxists or Communist), Pakistanis and Mullas, fanning cast hatred, they sometimes choose a Brahmin identity sometimes a Dalit identity and fuel hatred. I would request everyone to beware.
Even though there is cast problem it can be managed, it will die natural death, it can be removed by less talking and more sincere effort. But these guys dont want that, they will loose their bread and butter.
Extreme fake ideologies propagated by so called liberals, Marxists, Naxalites, Authors, Politicians. Who for sake of something, they term a accident involving two people as atrocity on one caste by other. This creates unnecessary sensation and hatred. Very extreme books have been authored with soul aim to gain applaud and make career as a writer, some kind of award etc. by people who have no interest in condition of poor.
Atrocities many times never come up, these exist in form of unsaid code, bias. But many times these are exaggerated, to take focus away from real problem of corruption and Islamic extremism. They try to say that there is something worse than Islamic extremism. I have not found a single example where complete caste groups had to vacate an area in number of more than few thousands, this happens only in case of Muslim extremism that non-Muslims have to vacate or die.
None of the guys in university campuses of JNU, Jadavpur, DU will talk about forced expulsion of Bangladeshi Hindus, though they themselves are son and daughter of refugees mostly. Most Bengalis have a grudge against Biharis and Bhaiyas filling up Kolkata, but Bangladeshi immigrant muslims are secular for them. I said to a Bihari guy in Mumbai, whatever Raj Thakre does, they wont commit genocide of Biharis. But if you support Congress, your sister will be abducted in front of your eyes and you will meet same fate as Hindus of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Kashmir. Same applies to cast problems, it is not the worst problem, worst is Islamic Jihad and corruption.
Atrocities many times never come up, these exist in form of unsaid code, bias. But many times these are exaggerated, to take focus away from real problem of corruption and Islamic extremism. They try to say that there is something worse than Islamic extremism. I have not found a single example where complete caste groups had to vacate an area in number of more than few thousands, this happens only in case of Muslim extremism that non-Muslims have to vacate or die.
None of the guys in university campuses of JNU, Jadavpur, DU will talk about forced expulsion of Bangladeshi Hindus, though they themselves are son and daughter of refugees mostly. Most Bengalis have a grudge against Biharis and Bhaiyas filling up Kolkata, but Bangladeshi immigrant muslims are secular for them. I said to a Bihari guy in Mumbai, whatever Raj Thakre does, they wont commit genocide of Biharis. But if you support Congress, your sister will be abducted in front of your eyes and you will meet same fate as Hindus of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Kashmir. Same applies to cast problems, it is not the worst problem, worst is Islamic Jihad and corruption.
Those who consider Shia, Christians, Jews, Yazidi, Buddhist as Kafir (50% sunni in Pakistan dont consider shia, 97% dont consider ahmedi to be muslim, 70% dont consider sufi Barelvi as Muslim) preach us. We give these scums opportunity. They only follow lines of our own leftists and so called liberals.
How can a Mohammad and Jesus humiliate everyone else as incapable of spirituality of higher truth? What is special in them which others dont have, how can a noble person say I am only one capable of connecting with spiritual and god and you all are not? On what merit u call everyone demerit? Why everyone should become slave of Mohammed or Jesus? Is not it slavery that we ourselves and our ancestors were incapable of wisdom and so we import and venerate and fight for mohammed?
In case Dalit and Persian have no intelligence in themselves and they need to become Muslims to get intelligence from other Muslims and they need to abandon their past culture then how can one say the existing Muslims were intelligent, same applies to them as well? They were also not intelligent and so they had to become Muslim, by mathematical backward induction all the way to nobody except Mohammad was intelligent.
How can a Mohammad and Jesus humiliate everyone else as incapable of spirituality of higher truth? What is special in them which others dont have, how can a noble person say I am only one capable of connecting with spiritual and god and you all are not? On what merit u call everyone demerit? Why everyone should become slave of Mohammed or Jesus? Is not it slavery that we ourselves and our ancestors were incapable of wisdom and so we import and venerate and fight for mohammed?
In all countries
where they went there was not a single worthy spiritual saint in the
past? Not in Iran? Not in pakistan? Not in Indonasia? Mighty King
Darius, Ahur Mazda were not worthy of respect in Iran? Sant Ramdas
was not venerable in India? Shabri was not venerable, sut putra Karna
cant be Hero? Are there not a single Dalit saint worthy or respect
and following in 0.5 Billion Dalits who have lived in India? Only
Mohammed or Jesus, why?
In case Dalit and Persian have no intelligence in themselves and they need to become Muslims to get intelligence from other Muslims and they need to abandon their past culture then how can one say the existing Muslims were intelligent, same applies to them as well? They were also not intelligent and so they had to become Muslim, by mathematical backward induction all the way to nobody except Mohammad was intelligent.
Dalit should remember not to ally with wolves because you have some problem with other Hindus. No dalit was spared in Pakistan, No muslim will marry your son without converting him to Islam and no Muslim will place Photo of Ambedkar in his home ever.
There is not a single mosque
or Church which will accept Budhha, Sant Ravidas, Kabir, Nanak...
Other Things
If there had been equal land distribution after 1947, we would not have faced so much disparity, condition was that 20% people owned 90% land. There is a reason why people in UP and Bihar have craze for IAS. It's a modern Zamindari system...feudal societies love it. Reservation is about representation. Govt jobs are not technical anyway. Reservation is about parity in administration. Think of a police station where all Sub inspectors are high caste, they will never treat a dalit or low caste fairly. Currently all castes live in separate quarters in police stations in Bihar, in engineering colleges, medical colleges. Even professors provide special help to their own cast students.
I agree to BJP MP Hukumdev Narain Yadav, he asked to make it a rule to give all jobs to people who are progeny of inter caste marriages. I guess that will help in eliminating discrimination. But high castes and upper OBCs will never agree to it, because they also know they dont want to take everyone together, they want their own benefit.
Problem of high cast poor remain, but they have relatives, friends who are well off and who can guide them, in uplifting from poverty. I think all high cast well off people should not take govt jobs so that more is available for poors, like LPG subsidy. Compared to high cast poor, most of dalits have almost nobody in family who owns land, who is well educated or holds a good position in govt office, they cant get help.
The kind of talk most people do, is not factual, not worth listening, it is mostly rumour. Most of caste groups have many rumours related to their cast, leaders, politics etc, which is far away from the reality, people always lean to extreme on other side.
Way Ahead: Long Term Need for Proper Mechanism to Identify Poor and Slowly Replacing Cast with Income Criteria
Reservation is not birth right till eternity, it has to go when there is more parity, and you cant create artificial dis-parity. When most people have access to basic education, health and shelter, reservation can be diluted. It is just a support. But until that time or until we develop alternate fair mechanism of helping poor and low castes, reservation should be there for them and it will be there as they have votes.
A mechanism for removing high income SC/ST/OBC from reservation and identifying mechanism to find out real poor regardless of class and slowly changing reservation to economic criteria (instead of caste) is need of hour, the process can take 50 years. If it is done correctly, it will be able to cover most of poor in dalits and poor in low castes. Presently Dalit and Low caste are afraid of economic based criteria being hijacked by few. At the same time, high cast who are extremely poor, they will also benefit (I must say mention here, the clamour against reservation is mostly by rich among high caste, not the poor, rich have enjoyed the bounty and they want it more).
Caste needs to be deconstructed and people need to be reorganized based on income so that poor benefit. This is not anti dalit, anti-OBC but pro, majority of them will benefit.
Those who outright want to reject reservation, have no idea what they are talking about. Similarly, groups benefiting reservation should try to acknowledge the feeling of poor among high cast, situation has changed, small land owning high cast in village have same situation as landless low caste.
If someone is truly interested in uplifting a caste, he should lead a movement for hygiene and 100% literacy, unlike burning shops and disrupting public facilities. Baba Saheb Ambedkar did not want reservation, he wanted education.
A mechanism for removing high income SC/ST/OBC from reservation and identifying mechanism to find out real poor regardless of class and slowly changing reservation to economic criteria (instead of caste) is need of hour, the process can take 50 years. If it is done correctly, it will be able to cover most of poor in dalits and poor in low castes. Presently Dalit and Low caste are afraid of economic based criteria being hijacked by few. At the same time, high cast who are extremely poor, they will also benefit (I must say mention here, the clamour against reservation is mostly by rich among high caste, not the poor, rich have enjoyed the bounty and they want it more).
Caste needs to be deconstructed and people need to be reorganized based on income so that poor benefit. This is not anti dalit, anti-OBC but pro, majority of them will benefit.
Those who outright want to reject reservation, have no idea what they are talking about. Similarly, groups benefiting reservation should try to acknowledge the feeling of poor among high cast, situation has changed, small land owning high cast in village have same situation as landless low caste.
If someone is truly interested in uplifting a caste, he should lead a movement for hygiene and 100% literacy, unlike burning shops and disrupting public facilities. Baba Saheb Ambedkar did not want reservation, he wanted education.
Muslims shouldnot complain because 75% muslims get reservation as OBC.
Anyone who is creating too much passion be it pro reservation or anti-reservation lobby, are enemies of nation.
It is time for sane reflection by everyone, penny wise and pounds fool has costed too much for nation.
It is time for sane reflection by everyone, penny wise and pounds fool has costed too much for nation.
There is lot more on stake, let us vow to maintain peace and brotherhood at all costs, let us be ready to loose or gain few jobs or things like that, much more awaits us in future if we can do that. See how Modiji manages everything, sacrificing even his respect many times.
No comments:
Post a Comment